Couple of days ago I had a long and unproductive conversation with a Russian correspondent on merits of Oath of Allegiance and, wider, on responsibilities of US Citizen vs. Resident Alien.
My opponent, like many contemporary Russians of his upbringing, didn’t see much difference between allegiance to country/to nation/to Constitution. I was trying to explain that the Oath request newcomers to denounce allegiance to foreign power, monarch and state – but does not require same allegiance to American state, but (as appropriate for free people) to Constitution and the Law. He was incensed:”I know that American nationals are good guys and they will not die for Constitution, some document written by oldies 200 years ago – but will take arms and die, like I would, for my country and state. What you are trying to tell me is slander” &&&.
I promised then to bring the topic here, quoting verbatim on twists and turns and ask for your input (after all, I didn’t have an advantage of studying “US Constitution” class in H.S., what do I know). So I am doing now, but half-heartedly. The reason being, I’ve listen through an hour-long video [via Ex-Dissident] explaining our current condition of the nation – the real State of the Union – and now am convinced: we are in free fall.
So, in this light, discussions like I described before are probably only of academic interest. Who cares about semantics, ideals and principles when house is devoured by fire…
, then




